| # | Title | Artist |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Carol of the Bells | Wilhousky, Peter J. |
| 2 | Joy to the World! | The Preacher's Wife |
| 3 | On Eagle's Wings | Joncas, Michael |
| 4 | May The Road Rise To Meet You | True, Lori |
| 5 | Homeward Bound | Keen, Marta |
| 6 | Sure On This Shining Night | Lauridsen, Morten |
| 7 | Hallelujah! | Jones, Quincy |
| 8 | Go Now In Peace | Besig, Don |
| 9 | Jolene | Wyatt, Stefan |
| 10 | The Little Drummer Boy | Pentatonix |
| 11 | That's Christmas to Me | Pentatonix |
| 12 | All Are Welcome | Haugen, Marty |
| 13 | Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | Hayes, Mark |
| 14 | Homeward Bound | Wilberg, Mack |
| 15 | Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | Hayes, Mark |
| 16 | Hallelujah | Cohen, Leonard |
| 17 | The Star-Spangled Banner | Key, Francis Scott |
| 18 | Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | Hayes, Mark |
| 19 | Northern Lights | Gjeilo, Ola |
| 20 | And So It Goes | Joel, Billy |
| 21 | We Are the World | USA for Africa |
| 22 | Hallelujah Chorus | Handel, George Frederick |
| 23 | The Seal Lullaby | Whitacre, Eric |
| 24 | Ave verum corpus, K. 618 | Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus |
| 25 | This Will Be (An Everlasting Love) | Cole, Natalie |
| 26 | I Will Always Love You | Parton, Dolly |
| 27 | Last Christmas | Wham! |
| 28 | Southern Gospel Medley | Anthem Lights |
| 29 | I Shall Wear a Crown | Whitfield, Thomas |
| 30 | Stand by Me | The Kingdom Choir |
| 31 | America Medley | Anthem Lights |
| 32 | You Raise Me Up | Groban, Josh |
| 33 | Blackbird | The Beatles |
| 34 | Taste And See | Moore Jr., James E. |
| 35 | Hail Holy Queen | Sister Act |
| 36 | What a Wonderful World | Armstrong, Louis |
| 37 | Come, Holy Spirit | Peterson, John W. |
| 38 | Homeward Bound | Keen, Marta |
| 39 | Homeward Bound | Keen, Marta |
| 40 | For All He's Done | Greater Vision |
| 41 | Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy | The Andrews Sisters |
| 42 | Homeward Bound | Keen, Marta |
| 43 | You Raise Me Up | Groban, Josh |
| 44 | Landslide | Glee |
| 45 | Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone) | BYU Noteworthy |
| 46 | Softly and Tenderly | Thompson, Will L. |
| 47 | Mary, Did You Know? | Pentatonix |
| 48 | The Sound of Silence | Pentatonix |
| 49 | O Holy Night | Adam, Adolphe Charles |
| 50 | Still, Still, Still | Eicker, Edward |